Opera omnia I
View publication
Book Series
Corpus Christianorum Continuatio Mediaevalis, vol. 312
Iacobus de Altavilla
Lectura in libros Sententiarum I
Principium, Questiones 1-6
Monica Brinzei, Chris Schabel (eds)
- Pages: cxxxii + 376 p.
- Size:155 x 245 mm
- Illustrations:6 tables b/w.
- Language(s):Latin, English
- Publication Year:2024
- € 425,00 EXCL. VAT RETAIL PRICE
- ISBN: 978-2-503-60725-2
- Hardback
- Available
The first critical edition of any major theological work by a Cistercian in a university context.
Review(s)
"Die ratio edendi, dargelegt auf einigen ausgesprochen lesenswerten Seiten (CII-CIX), hatte unterschiedlichen Vor- und Maßgaben Rechnung zu tragen. Bei Editionen solchen Umfangs, tausende von Seiten zählend und in einer Vielzahl von Textzeugen überliefert, müssen praktisch-pragmatische Erwägungen eine zentrale Rolle spielen. Zentral ist die Beschränkung des kritischen Apparats auf ein Minimum. Doch wie wird man dabei legitimen Anforderungen beispielsweise von Historikern gerecht, die aus dem apparatus criticus wertvolle Informationen etwa zur Rezeptionsgeschichte des Textes ziehen wollen? Die Antwort der Editoren erscheint einfach(...), verschleiert jedoch das Ausmaß an editorischer Vorbildung und Erfahrungswissen, die nötig sind, um solcherart Entscheidungen treffen, den 'goldenen Mittelweg' überhaupt finden zu können. Der im vorliegenden Fall eingeschlagene Weg zur Entscheidungsfindung, d.h. zur Reduktion der für die Edition maßgeblichen Handschriften, wird für den Leser unmittelbar einsichtig rekonstruiert - und überzeugt auf breiter Linie (...) Die Editoren schließen ihr Vorwort mit einem bescheidenen Wunsch: Editoribus detur bonum vinum. Der Rezensent hofft, dass dies inzwischen geschehen ist. Verdient hätten sie es." (Ralf Lützelschwab, in Sehepunkte, 24.12, 2024)
BIO
Chris Schabel, former Professor of Medieval History at the University of Cyprus, is currently associated researcher at the CNRS (IRHT, Aubervilliers). His publications focus on the Latin East, Greek-Latin intellectual relations, and later-medieval intellectual history.
Monica Brinzei is Directrice de recherche at the CNRS (IRHT, Aubervilliers), principal investigator of the ERC projects THESIS (2012-2018) and DEBATE (2018-2024), and leader of the French team of the Horizon 2020 project RESTORY (2024-2026). She specializes in the history of later-medieval universities.
From Babeș-Bolyai University, Cluj-Napoca: Dr. Alexandra Anisie (researcher in the ERC-NOTA project), Dr. Alexandra Baneu (PI of ERC Nota project and researcher at the Romanian Academy), Prof. Alexander Baumgarten, Dr. Luciana Cioca, Dr. Daniel Coman, Dr. Ioana Curuţ (MSCA Seal of Excellence-RABY project), Dr. Andrei Marinca (Lecturer), Dr. Madalina Pantea (researcher in the ERC-NOTA), all of them previously team members in the ERC THESIS project, explore via their studies, editions, and translations the tradition of the Sentences in the fourteenth and fifteen centuries.
Summary
This is the first critical edition of a major theological work by a Cistercian from a medieval university: the questions on book I of the Sentences by James of Eltville (Jacobus de Altavilla, d. 1392), monk and later abbot of the majestic Eberbach Abbey, the filming location of many of the scenes in The Name of the Rose. The product of bachelor lectures delivered in 1369-1370 at the magnificent Bernardins in Paris just south of Notre-Dame across the Seine, James' Lectura in libros Sententiarum survives in almost two dozen manuscripts. Based on a complete collation of all the witnesses, the editio princeps provides access to a text that illuminates a relatively dark period in the history of scholasticism, portrays the status quaestionis on many issues in philosophical theology between the Black Death and the Great Schism, and illustrates the importance of later-medieval Cistercian theologians and their symbiotic relationship with the Augustinian Hermits who dominated the field from the 1330s to the 1370s. Through the exodus of German scholars from Paris after the outbreak of the Schism, James of Eltville's ideas spread to the new faculties of theology founded in Germanic lands where they exerted a profound influence.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Preface
Introduction
I. Biographical Note
II. Context of the Edition
III. Sigla of the Manuscripts
IV. Description of the Manuscripts
V. Tabula quaestionum
VI. Chart of Manuscripts and Questions of Book I
VII. Stemmatic Discussion and ratio edendi
Bibliography
Abbreviations
Primary Sources
Secondary Literature
Iacobi de Altavilla Lectura In Libros Sententiarum
Principium: Utrum Deus ad quamlibet speciem entis creabilis se habens distanter infinite in aliqua specie intellectuali a nobis nominari possit quidditative
Questio 1 (Questio 1 Prologi): Utrum veritates theologice scientie contrarientur seu repugnent veritatibus principiorum naturalis luminis et sensualis experientie
Questio 2 (Questio 2 Prologi): Utrum studens in Sacra Scriptura non credens sicut sancta credit Ecclesia erret
Questio 3 (Questio 1 distinctionis 1 libri 1): Utrum pro studio sacre theologie ex caritate procedente debeatur pro mercede visio Dei et eius fruitio
Questio 4 (Questio 2 distinctionis 1 libri 1): Utrum inter creature totius usum et Dei solius fruitionem licitum sit rationali creature facere aliquo modo commutationem
Questio 5 (Questio un. distinctionis 2 libri 1): Utrum creatura rationalis viatrix vel beata infallibilem habere possit notitiam de divina essentia
Questio 6 (Questio 1 distinctionum 2-3 libri 1): Utrum in entibus fore unum primum seu Deum unicum possit a viatore efficaciter esse scitum
Indices
Index locorum Sacrae Scripturae
Index fontium
